| 21-Jul-2022 |
Smt. Asha
and Sh. Naresh Kumar, Chartered Accountant briefed the facts of the case and Sh
Laxmi kant Saini (Expert/consultant) has been present on behalf of the
authority. Sh. Sagar Gupta (AGM (F&A) is present on behalf of the promoter.
In View of the recommendation made above the authority has decided to permit
the registration certificate remain in force. On the basis of facts narrated
above in the brief by the chartered accountant and after considering the reason
for delay in completing the project within the time declared by the promoter
under section 4(2)(l)(C) and even after lapse of admissible extension time of
one year and also giving an opportunity of hearing in this regard to the
promoter in the preceding hearings authority decided to impose penalty of Rs. 1
crore for violation of section 4 to be deposited as mention in the
recommendation of the expert/consultant assign the work of examining due
diligence report and SWAMIH fund term sheet issued for this project being
stressed and SBI Cap Venture Fund approval. This will be without prejudice to
the rights of the individual allottees with respect to due date of possession
as per BBA. |
EXTENSION APPROVED |
--- |
| 12-Jul-2022 |
Sh. Asha and Sh.
Naresh Kumar, Chartered Accountant briefed the facts of the case Sh. Sagar
Gupta (AGM (F&A) is present on behalf of the promoter. The Promoter has
intimated that as on date the tower A to D and EWS of the project are complete
in all respect and promoter has applied for grant of occupation certificate to
DTCP Haryana on 04.04.2022. The Promoter has cleared all the deficiencies. Keeping
in view of the above and recommendation made by the expert/consultant and
chartered accountant of the authority, the authority has decided to issue
public notice for inviting objection from the allottee in particular and other
concerned persons in this regard. objections if any, arise after the publication
of notice that may dealt separately in separate proceedings.The matter be come up on 21.07.2022. |
ADJOURNMENT |
--- |
| 05-Jul-2022 |
Mr Naresh Kumar, Chartered Accountant
briefed the facts of the case Sh. Sagar Gupta
(AGM (F&A) is present on behalf of the
promoter. The AR assures to make the requisite rectification of deficiencies
within next week. The matter to come up
on 12.07.2022. |
ADJOURNMENT |
--- |
| 02-May-2022 |
The matter adjourned for dated 05.07.2022 |
ADJOURNMENT |
--- |
| 13-Apr-2022 |
The matter adjourned for dated 02.05.2022 |
ADJOURNMENT |
--- |
| 11-Apr-2022 |
Sh. Sagar Gupta (AGM F&A), Sh. Mohit Dhamija (AM F&A), Sh. Arun Kumar (GM) and Ms. Usha Sharma (Architect) are present on behalf of the promoter. Promoter was asked to deposit deficit fees of Rs. 1195346 and pending QPR reports along with Annual Audit Report for the financial year 2018-19 & 2019-20. The matter to come up on 13.04.2021 |
ADJOURNMENT |
--- |
| 25-Jan-2022 |
The deficiencies were conveyed to the promoter through online hearing. Promoter was asked to submit deficient documents. The matter to come up on 11.04.2021 |
OBJECTION |
--- |
| 12-Jan-2022 |
Proceedings dated: 12.01.2022
Sh. Sagar Gupta (AR) and Ms. Usha Sharma (AR) joined the
hearing through VC and submitted that an application for grant of extension
upto 31.12.2021 was submitted on
29.10.2020. However, due to non renewal of building plan and renewal of
environmental clearance and non submission of approved service plan and
estimates, the extension could not be granted. The registration of the above
project was valid upto 31.03.2020 and by allowing extension of 6 months due to
COVID-19, the registration could be considered valid upto 30.09.2020 only. The
section 6 of 2016 Act provides a maximum extension of one year which could be
granted upto 30.09.2021 only. The AR submits that the construction work has
been completed and final finishing work are in progress at site but could not
be completed owing to second wave of COVID-19 and restrictions of NGT etc.
Therefore, the AR of promoter requests for grant of extension upto March, 2022
by which time the occupation certificate shall be obtained as the grant of fire
NOC already stand submitted to the concerned authority as required before grant
of OC.
However, under section 6(3) there is no provision to grant
extension beyond one year but in interest of allottees for completion of the
project, the extension could be considered under section 7(3) of the said Act.
The AR seeks 2 weeks time for submission of the requisite application along
with requisite documents.
The matter to come up on 25.01.2022. |
OBJECTION |
--- |
| 22-Dec-2021 |
Proceedings dated: 22.12.2021No one is present on behalf of the promoter. A show cause notice was
issued on 16.11.2021. In continuation to the same show cause notice the
promoter is hereby given an opportunity of hearing if promoter has to say
anything regarding as why their application for grant of registration shall not
be rejected on account of various deficiencies as has been conveyed earlier and
also detailed at the time of hearing on 13.12.2021.
The matter to come up on 12.01.2022 |
OBJECTION |
--- |
| 13-Dec-2021 |
Proceedings dated: 13.12.2021
Ms. Jyoti Yadav, Coordinator Planning briefed the
facts about the project.
Sh. Sagar Gupta (AGM F&A), Sh. Mohit Dhamija (AM
F&A), Sh. Arun Kumar (GM) and Ms. Usha Sharma (Architect) are present on
behalf of the promoter. The hard copy of DPI after corrections is being
submitted today. Further the AR assures to submit the remaining deficit
documents including certificate of CA for non-default of loan, CA certificate for
financial and inventory details, annual report under section 4(2)(l)(D) of the
Act. No dues towards EDC accounts statement also needs to be submitted.
The matter to come up on 22.12.2021. |
ADJOURNMENT |
--- |
| 07-Dec-2021 |
The matter is adjourned for 13.12.2021 |
ADJOURNMENT |
--- |
| 06-Dec-2021 |
The hearing is adjourned and matter to come up on 07.12.2021. |
ADJOURNMENT |
--- |
| 16-Nov-2021 |
Proceedings dated: 16.11.2021
Ms. Jyoti Yadav, Coordinator Planning briefed the facts about
the project.
Sh. Sagar Gupta (AGM F&A) and Sh. Mohit Dhamija (AM
F&A) are present on behalf of the promoter.
The promoter has defaulted in depositing penalty imposed on
him in earlier cases where extension was granted under section 7(3) and it was
also observed that the promoter failed to show reasonable circumstance and
without default on his part there was delay in executing the projects namely
Skyz, Rise, Edge Tower A to G, N and O being part of project in sector 37-D. The present license No.12 of 2009 consists of
13.156 acres wherein the promoter got registered only part of the project
admeasuring 3.257 acres whereas remaining part remains un-registered. Promoter
is advised to get the registration done of the whole project as there is single
license, single approval of building plans and other approvals or get the
phasing done from the competent authority.
The reasons quoted by the promoter regarding delay are as
under :-
1 Delay occurred due to NGT ban and
followed pandemic of covid-19, which has brought the cash flow to a standstill.
2 Actual shortage of labours at site.
3 Ban on use of diesel generators sets for a
period of 1.5 months.
The project was
registered on 23.8.2018 vide registration number 21 of 2018 valid upto 31.03.2020
plus six months covid relaxation the validity was extended upto 30.09.2020. The
promoter applied late after expiry of the validity of registration on
29.10.2020. Even then the application
was incomplete, and matter was fixed on fourteen different hearings. Even today there are deficiencies as have
been detailed in the agenda. The
promoter is advised to attend the deficiencies within a week otherwise show
cause notice be issued under section 6 with an opportunity of hearing to the
promoter.
The reasons for
delay were considered by the authority and it was found that for reasonable
circumstances such as covid-19, 6 months grace period has already been allowed
and all other reasons quoted by the promoter does not seems to be reasonable
and without default on part of promoter. Although the matter is strictly not covered under section 6 where extension
is allowed by the authority if reasonable circumstances without default on the
part of the promoter based on facts on
each case but keeping in view the public interest in completing the project and
reading section 7(3) with section 6 authority decided to consider the application
for registration without prejudice to initiate penal proceedings for failure of
the promoter to complete the project within time period declared under section
4(2)(l)(c).
The authority
decided to issue show cause as to why penalty of Rs. One crore (which is even
less than 0.5 percent of the project cost) shall not be imposed on the promoter
for failure to complete the project within the declared time period under
section 4(2)(l)(c) without reasonable circumstances and without default on
their part. The reply to this show cause shall be submitted within two weeks
and an opportunity of personal hearing is granted at 3-00 PM on the next date
of hearing.
The promoter by his
conduct cannot be rely as in almost all the projects there is delay or one can
say abnormal delay and also failure on the part of the promoter to adhere to
the orders of the authority and failure to deposit the penalty as has been
ordered while deciding extension cases of the project mentioned above. The
promoter is again advised to deposit the penalty immediately. The online
project information has been submitted today only which is to be examined by
the office and put up before the authority for its consideration.
The authority
considers it expedient to obtain a site report regarding the stage of
completion of the project. Engineer Executive Shri Sumit Nain along with Ms.
Neeraj Gautam Architect Executive to visit the site within a week and submit
its report. Site visit be intimated to
the promoter for submitting necessary documents regarding their claim of stage
of construction/project is nearly completion.
It was submitted by
the AR (Shri Sagar Gupta-AGM-Finance) that 104 units in the project are
unsold. The authority hereby orders ban
on sale of the units by the promoter before compliance of orders of the
authority as has been narrated above exercising powers under section 36 of the
Act of 2016.
Matter to come up on 06.12.2021. |
OBJECTION |
--- |
| 28-Oct-2021 |
Proceedings dated: 28.10.2021
Ms. Jyoti Yadav, Coordinator Planning briefed the
facts about the project.
Sh. Sagar Gupta (AGM F&A) and Sh. Mohit
Dhamija (AM F&A) are present on behalf of the
promoter.
The Authority directed the promoter to submit the
deficit documents along with hard copy of online DPI after filling all the
requisite details.
The matter to come up on 16.11.2021. |
ADJOURNMENT |
--- |
| 26-Oct-2021 |
THE MATTER IS ADJOURNED FOR 28.10.2021 |
ADJOURNMENT |
--- |
| 20-Sep-2021 |
THE MATTER IS ADJOURNED FOR 26.10.2021 |
ADJOURNMENT |
--- |
| 06-Sep-2021 |
Ms. Jyoti Yadav, Coordinator, Planning Branch briefed the facts of the project.Sh. Sagar Gupta (AGM-F&A) is present on behalf of the promoter.The promoter has declared date of completion of this part of the project as 31.12.2021 which may be considered by the Authority keeping in view 3 months’ time period additionally provided due to COVID-19 second wave. The promoter is not serious about completing the deficient documents. The promoter has also received a show cause notice for rejection of the application for grant of extension, but no reply has been submitted by the promoter. The last opportunity is granted to the promoter for attending deficiencies and submitting requisite documents. The promoter is also advised to apply for registration of the left-out area of the license.The matter to come up on 20.09.2021. |
ADJOURNMENT |
--- |
| 17-May-2021 |
Due to Covid-19 pandemic, authority meeting could not be held. Now, the authority has decided to fix the matter on 06.09.2021. |
OBJECTION |
--- |
| 26-Apr-2021 |
Proceedings dated: 26.04.2021 Ms. Jyoti Yadav, Coordinator, Planning Branch briefed the facts of the case. No one is present on behalf of the promoter. An e-mail has been received from the promoter on 26.04.2021 regarding adjournment of hearing. The Authority granted adjournment of three weeks. The matter to come up on 17.05.2021.Dr. K.K.Khandelwal (Chairman)Samir Kumar (Member)Vijay Kumar Goyal (through video conferencing) |
OBJECTION |
--- |
| 24-Mar-2021 |
Sh. Sagar Gupta (AGM Finance), Sh.Rajiv .Saraswat (GM Projects) and Mrs. Usha Sharma (DGM, Arch) are present on behalf of the promoter. The license No. 12 of 2009 was granted by DTCP on 21.5.2009 for development of Group Housing over 13.156 acre in Sector 37 D of Gurugram. The said license is valid upto 20. 5.2024 and the approval of building plans is upto 24.4.2023 except for EWS Block for which extension has already been applied. The approval of service plan estimates and environment clearance has also been obtained and are valid. Further the registration of the project from HARERA has been obtained and was valid upto 31.09.2020 after including six months COVID period.. However, the project could not be completed and thus as requested for extension of one year three months i.e. upto 31.12.2021. It was noticed that extension for only one year can be granted after removal of the following deficiencies:1. The project is to be developed in phases and approval as per section 4(2)(l)(C) be obtained beyond its validity period and upto proposed extension. The registration for the entire project will be required within 15 days of approval of phasing plan by DTCP without prejudice to the action to be taken under section 59 of the Act. 3. Audit report under section 4(2)(l)(D) needs to be provided.4. Quarterly Progress Report of the project needs to be provided for all the quarters.5. Delay possession charges shall be paid by the promoter to the concerned allottees as per section 18 of RERA Act. It is clarified that the time period granted for this part of the project is upto getting CC/part CC not OC of some of the buildings. Matter to come up for compliance of the conditions as above after four weeks i.e. 26.4.2021. |
ADJOURNMENT |
--- |
| 22-Feb-2021 |
Hearing adjourned and fixed for 22.02.2021 |
OBJECTION |
--- |
| 08-Feb-2021 |
The deficiencies were conveyed to the promoter
through online hearing. Promoter was asked to submit deficient documents and
also approved phasing of the project from DTCP. The matter to come up on 22.02.2021.
|
ADJOURNMENT |
--- |
| 11-Jan-2021 |
The matter has been adjourned since the Coram is not complete. The next date of hearing is 08.02.2021 |
OBJECTION |
--- |
| 10-Dec-2020 |
The matter has been adjourned since the Coram is not complete. The next date of hearing is 10.12.2020 |
ADJOURNMENT |
--- |
| 07-Dec-2020 |
The matter has been adjourned since the Coram is not complete. The next date of hearing is 10.12.2020 |
ADJOURNMENT |
--- |
| 23-Nov-2020 |
The matter has been adjourned since the Coram
is not complete.
The next date of hearing is
07.12.2020 at 3:00p.m. |
EXAMINATION BY AUTHORITY |
--- |