| 30-Jan-2025 |
DISPOSED |
Ar. Neeraj Gautam (Associate Architectural Executive) briefed the facts of the
case.
Sh. Vipin Kumar and Ms.
Gargi Bhatt appeared on behalf of the promoter and requests to condone the
delay. He has handed over written submissions with respect to show cause notice
dated 17.12.2024 wherein it is stated that the developer had applied for
revised service plans and estimates and revised fire scheme immediately after
the issuance of RERA registration certificate by the Authority. However, since
the same being a lengthy and time-consuming process, the undersigned developer
vide application bearing dak ID 52216 dated 25.04.2023 requested the Authority
to extend the time period for submission of revised service plans &
estimates and revised fire scheme approval from 02.05.2023 to 17.07.2023 and
that application is still pending for consideration before the Authority.
It is further stated in the
application the revised fire scheme application was moved vide receipt dated
24.03.2023 and the same was received after approval only vide memos dated
17.05.2023 and 16.06.2023, respectively taking almost a period of two months
and even more and for considerable period, there was no officer/ competent
authority to deal with the request for issuance of revised fire scheme. So, the
requisite approval could not be issued and submitted. Similarly, the revised
service plans and estimates applied by the company and forwarded by Chief
Engineer- I, HSVP Panchkula vide memo dated 13.04.2023 were received from the
Directorate of Town and Country Planning, Haryana vide memo dated 09.06.2023.
Thus, there is no fault of the company in either of the two situations. The
time taken by those authorities in processing and passing orders on the
applications moved by the company w.r.t. revised service plans and estimates
and revised fire scheme approval took about 2 and 3 months respectively and the
company has no control over the same. Even, the Hon’ble Apex Court of the land
while dealing with such type of situations excluded the period spent in
pursuing litigation before the competent authorities and took the same view in
cases of Laxmi Srinivasa R and P Boiled Rice Mill V/s State of Andhra Pradesh
and Anr. 2022 LiveLaw (SC) 964, Consolidated & Ors (2008) 7 SCC 169 and
recently followed in Purni Devi & Anr. v/s Babu Ram & Anr 92024) 4 SCR
37. The promoter requests to consider the case sympathetically and order refund/
release the subject security amount with interest.
The Authority decided in its
meeting dated 01.01.2024 that the compliances by the promoters must be made
without fail within the timeline of conditional registration failing which the
BG/ security be forfeited and further action be initiated as per the provisions
of the Act of 2016.
It is not disputed that the
promoter was granted conditional registration at its own accord and depositing
of security amount in the form of demand draft in lieu of submission of the
requisite clearances within the time specified in the conditional registration.
It was clearly mentioned in the registration certificate that these cheques shall
be forfeited in case the respective conditions are not fulfilled by the
promoter within the stipulated time period mentioned in the conditions.
In view of the above, the
security amount submitted in lieu of timely submission of the approved revised
service plans and estimates, and approved revised fire scheme is hereby
forfeited.
Since the compliance has now
been made, although with a delay, the case is filed.
Detailed order shall follow. |
ASHOK SANGWAN |
View Order |
10-Feb-2025 |